Welcome to MIKE & MARIO'S ITALIAN RESTAURANT
Mike & Mario's Italian Restaurant is a cozy spot in Staunton, VA that transforms your ordinary meal into an Italian culinary experience. Nestled at 1010 Churchville Ave, it stands out with its welcoming atmosphere and genuine recipes that reflect authentic Italian flavors. Known for its delicious pizza, fresh subs, and hearty pasta dishes, this establishment captures the essence of Italy right in your neighborhood. With a reasonable price range of $10 to $20, it offers something for everyone — whether you're grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a relaxed dinner with family or friends. Plus, they provide delivery and takeaway options for those on the go.
Popular dishes
Restaurant Gallery
About
Located conveniently at 1010 Churchville Ave, Mike & Mario's Italian Restaurant is a beloved gem in the Staunton community. This family-owned eatery thrives on creating connections over food, making it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. The restaurant prides itself on serving authentic Italian cuisine, including pizza that rivals that found in Naples, Italy, as reported by enthusiastic customers. Its casual, cozy atmosphere makes it perfect for families, couples, or solo diners looking to enjoy comfort food in a relaxed setting. Accessibility is also a plus, featuring wheelchair-accessible entrances and seating, ensuring everyone can enjoy a meal here.
Mike & Mario’s is a go-to spot for lunch and dinner. Expect a fun community vibe with friendly staff and solid dishes that the locals swear by. On busy weekends, particularly Saturday evenings, the restaurant fills up, reflecting its popularity. To beat the rush, consider visiting during off-peak hours, such as Monday afternoons or later in the week. The full-service dining experience is complemented by free parking options nearby, making it easy for customers to pop in for a meal or order to go.
Working Hours
- SundayOpen
- MondayOpen
- TuesdayOpen
- WednesdayOpen
- ThursdayOpen
- FridayOpen
- SaturdayOpen
What People Say
Most Liked
Patrons rave about the authentic taste of the pizza, consistently mentioned for its perfect consistency and lack of excess grease, unlike many competitors. The marinara sauce garners high praise, with many visitors saying it enhances every pizza and pasta dish.
The friendly atmosphere and attentive service really set Mike & Mario's apart. Customers often mention the quick turnover of tables, showing a dedicated staff that keeps the dining area clean and welcoming. The menu variety, featuring both traditional Italian entrees and American favorites, means there's something for everyone, including kids.
Desserts like cannoli, cheesecake, and chocolate cake make for an indulgent finish after a hearty meal. Customers feel like they struck gold finding this hidden treasure in Staunton.
Most Disliked
While most reviews are highly positive, a few customers have pointed out that the dining area can get crowded during peak hours, especially on Saturday evenings, leading to longer wait times for a table or service.
Some diners have mentioned that a few dishes can be a tad inconsistent in flavor or preparation. While these instances are rare, there have been mentions of the occasional overcooked pasta or less-than-ideal serving temperatures.
The absence of outdoor seating options has also been noted, which some guests miss during warm weather.
Reviews
wyatt a.
We had the margarita pizza, chefs salad, and the vegitarian sub, and every bit of it was great. The pizza especially was very authentic to italian naples pizza i had when I went to naples Italy. Fantastic service, and I hope this helps them generate more customers.
Barbara M.
I really enjoy this restaurant. We usually pick up our order because we live about a mile away. While waiting for my order to be completed (if I get there too early) the dining room is always clean. I have seen the employees clear a table almost as soon as the people left. We have ordered soup, salad, pasta, pizza, and subs and everything has been wonderful. The employees are always polite and helpful. The owners are very friendly. They employ teenagers and I have had good experiences from them. The thing that we order most often is pizza. We have tried multiple places in the area and everybody makes the pizza soooo greasy. This is the only place that DOES NOT. This is our go-to place for pizza now.
Melvin J.
Mike and Mario’s is the best place for Italian food. We always stop in to eat when we are in the area. The food is great and I can’t say enough good things about the family owned business. The marinara is amazing and they get all of their sub rolls delivered from NJ. If you’re in the Staunton Va area do not pass by and not stop to eat. It’s your own fault it you do. Also a great selection of delicious desserts too.
gamerman 5.
Once you go here once, you will want to keep coming back. Food taste amazing and portions are perfect for the price you pay. I highly recommend the steak stromboli. This place is #1 for me.
marsha m.
Fantastic authentic Italian food. Best calzone in Staunton. We were not expecting to find this jewel. We had calzones. The sauce was fantastic and the toppings and dough were cooked to perfection. This is hard to find. Fabulous food. Believe me this rivals little Italy in Boston.
Seon K.
Their cheese is THE BEST. I’ll come back later to eat again, it’s worth driving more than an hour. I enjoyed their sauce and every other toppings. Their fries are freshly served and cannot be compared with other food chain. Highly recommended!
Curtis S.
Pizza and salad are always tasty. Decent Ranch dressing. And nice folks at the counter. My favorite local joint. Small parking lot was full so that’s a good sign.